Search our Archives:
» Opinion & Society
The British Called Me a Terrorist...
by Dr. Matania Ginosar
When I joined the Israeli underground LECHI at fifteen the British, and
most Israelis, called me a terrorist and tried to arrest and even kill
whoever they could from our meager membership. Before I joined LECHI, an
Israeli told the police where our leader Avraham Stern was hiding and
British detectives murdered him while hiding in a closet. We were called
"the Stern Gang," the British murdered most of our leaders, and arrested
almost all the rest. One member, who later became my friend, Yehoshua
Cohen, who many years later became the bodyguard of Ben Gurion,
resurrected us from obscurity and build up our dedicated teams (cells)
slowly, spreading them over the country. Many of our leaders escaped
prison by digging a hundred and fifty feet tunnel and re-joined the fight.
Many other dedicated members died, including my cell leader, Mordechai. I
was lucky, I just spent a short time in jail. My brother spent nearly two
years in a British detention camp in Africa with hundreds of other freedom
fighters. His wife, a freedom fighter too, was arrested with him, and
served time in prison.
I knew in my soul, as my friends did too, that Israel was ours and the
British would have to leave, no matter how long it would take, and how
many of us would die in that fight. All my education, my upbringing, my
inner feelings told me that one day, all this area would, again, be our
land. We expected the local Arabs and Christians to live in our Jewish
State as equal citizens.
We called ourselves Lochamai Cherut Israel, (LECHI), "Fighters for the
Freedom of Israel," and after years of fighting the British alone, we
convinced the other two undergrounds, the Irgun and Hagana, to fight
together our enemy - Britain. All three underground groups then coordinated their
attacks on British installations, making effort Not To Kill even their
soldiers unless it was necessary. We raised so much hell for them that
they finally asked the UN to take over. And we got a sliver of a free state.
Terroists and Freedom Fighters, The Difference:
Were we terrorists or freedom fighters? Terrorists aim to create terror in
the civilian population by killing innocent civilians, men, women and
children. The freedom fighters of Israel did their best to prevent killing not only Britsh civilians, but also
British policemen. One of our underground members hated the British
and killed a policeman without orders. We warned him, but he did it again.
One of our leaders killed him under orders.
We had many opportunities to
kill British policemen, but we targeted only those that killed and tortured our
members while prisoners.
When the Irgun underground decided to blow up the
King David Hotel, a British headquarter, they warned the British half an
hour earlier, but the British could not believe that the Irgun could
penetrate their command center and did not evacuate it. Their arrogance
caused the death of many people, including civilians.
Why am I telling this old story now? Because I am concerned about the way
some Americans, and painfully some Jews, misunderstand the situation in
Israel and what occurred there for the last hundred years, and now. Some
still blame Israel for the agony there. Some withhold their support
because they find lack of perfection in this Jewish State, which is
fighting continuously for its survival. Some sit here in judgement on a
state and people of which they have little understanding.
When Israel was celebrating its fiftieth anniversary, my picture was on the
front page of the Sacramento Bee and my family's participation in the
liberation of Israel was told inside, written by a "liberal" Jew. The
writer emphasized the suffering of the Palestinians, with little
understanding of the suffering of the Israelis. After all, the Israelis
are the "strong" ones, therefore the "bad" ones. (Most of the media
approach the Arab-Israel problem that way.) The article in the Bee was
nicely done, sanitized, the way most Americans want to see this story.
Most of us like to have things nicely packaged, refraining from seeing the
pictures of true agony in order to continue our lives without too much
involvement. Much of this shield was broken on September 11. We started to
see the world in truer colors. I hope we can now see the Israeli story
also as it really is, and not through the utopian eyes of unrealistic
I don't know if I can reach people with these words, but I want to try.
Please understand that most people know very little about the utterly
desolated, and unpopulated land Palestine was 100 years ago, when Jews
started to come to Israel in increasing numbers. The Jews did not displace
anybody; it was nearly an empty land. Americans know very little about the
Arab pogroms in Israel starting in earnest in 1929 when my sister-in-law's
family escaped Arab murderers in Hebron by sheer luck, but 69 others Jews
did not. You may know about the MURDERS OF THOUSANDS ISRAELIS
by Arab armies and Palestinians to date, but it did not touch you
personally like it still does the majority of Israeli families. You heard,
but you do not know how much the Israelis scarified to live on this thin
sliver of a land just five percent the size of California. Yes, twenty
Israel's can be placed inside California, and this current sliver is a
tiny fraction of the land we expected to have as the Jewish Homeland when
I was growing up there.
Please allow me to tell you a little of my own family experience in Israel so that
you may start to feel a little of the agonies that the Jews of Israel
went, and are going, through. The dream of my family for an Israeli State was
not different from the dreams of most Jews. My father was two years
old when his parents left Russia to go to Cairo, Egypt. They hoped to go
to Israel, but the poverty and severe occupation of the Turkish Ottoman
Empire was so hard that Jews already there left Israel to live in the
British-controlled Egypt. A few years later my mother and her family left
Metulla, on donkeys, in the Galil of northern Israel, because of starvation and torment
under the Turks, to Cairo, after
living there a hundred and fifty years.
When my father was seventeen the British Government issued the Balfour
Declaration giving their support to the creation of a Jewish State on the
TWO SIDES OF THE JORDAN RIVER (as it was in biblical times). After the
British conquered the Middle East in 1918, and promised the Jews to help
them create a state on the two sides of the Jordan, my father and many of
his friends moved to Israel to build the new state. In 1922 Churchill
created Trans Jordan and gave three quarters of the land promised to be
Israel to the Arabs. The smaller portion, ALL THE LAND BETWEEN THE JORDAN
AND THE SEA was to be a TEMPORARY British Mandate under the League of
Nation DEDICATED TO THE CREATION THE STATE OF ISRAEL in that full area.
My older brother, my sister, and I were raised to continue our hope for an
Israel on both sides of the Jordan, and to fight to achieve that goal. We
did not accept the duplicity of the British, cutting down our country to
its minimum size. You may say it was an unrealistic dream, but that was
part of our soul, an integral part of who we were. And we fought for it,
as many other Israelis did. The Left and the Hagana accepted the shrinking
of Israel, the Right, and the Irgun and Lechi undergrounds did not. We
were still hoping.
As the UN divided Israel in 1947 to an Arab and Israeli portion, our
hearts were cut again. It was a severe blow to our dreams, but we wanted a
Jewish State to accept the millions of wondering, stateless Jews; and
eventually most Israelis, including my father, my brother, my sister, and
I, accepted that sad reality. I accepted this reality despite the Arabs
killing a quarter of my elementary and highschool friends during the war
of 1947-48 that they imposed on us, despite them killing three of my
kibbutz friends, out of forty members, in "peace time" after the 1948 war.
We wanted bygones to be bygones.
You may have read about the anguish in Israel, but unless you went through
this yourself, with your relatives and friends dying in one war or
another, or by a suicide bomber, you are not likely to feel it like an
Israeli feels it. Almost all Israelis have a friend or a relative that was
injured or killed in the many attacks or wars imposed on them. And still
these Israelis want peaceful coexistence, minimize civilian casualties,
and do not lash out, as some other nations would have done. Millions of refugees were resettled around the world in the last fifty years,
starting new lives, but not the Palestinians. They want all of the land of Israel,
from the river to the sea, and clearly state that their aim is to have
whatever land they can get now, so it could be used as a springboard to
take over all the land from the Jordan to the Sea.
Unlike the Palestinians, we did not accept this sliver of land as a step
to take over all the land. It may be that a small number still dream about that
larger Israel, but most Israelis want to build the country and bring in as
many Jews as possible and accepted the reality with a heavy heart.
People from around the world, and especially painful to me, are some American
Jews, who tell the Israelis, "be practical, give this or give that to get peace."
First, it does not work - Barak tried it. He offered 98% of the land that the Palestinians demanded plus
parts of Jerusalem. But I wonder how many here are willing to be so
generous and return parts of California that were taken by force from
Mexico not so long ago. It is almost the same time frame that Jews came to
rebuild Israel in the late nineteen century. A friend answered me: "but
the Mexicans have their own country." Yes, the Palestinians have their own
country too: Jordan. About 80% of Jordan's population are Palestinians!
And it is just right there, the other side of the Jordan River. DESPITE
THAT the Israelis accept the reality that the Palestinians should have
their own land; the Israeli just want peace with their neighbors.
The Palestinians claim that the Israelis took their lands. IT IS NOT TRUE
and we can, needlessly, argue about it for a long time. Some say, see how
much the Palestinians suffer loosing their lands. Israelis suffered no
less from the slicing of their promised lands, reducing it from the two
sides of the Jordan and then cutting it to the current sliver of land.
The question is what to do with the reality of today?
What can be done now so that both people can live in peace and
The answer is simply that for the Palestinians to have a good life
they must accept our reality, stop the terror, and give peace a chance.
Dr. Ginosar has published a book about his Lechi underground experience:
Israeli Freedom Fighter. To contact Dr. Ginosar write:
from the February 2003 Edition of the Jewish Magazine